People's First Insurance


We have excellent plans available through reputable auto insurers.


If you have any questions about the level of auto coverage that's right for you, we have plans available through reputable auto insurers.


Read More


Your home purchase is an investment deserving protection.


Insure the investment you’ve made with a homeowners plan. Let us assist in you in finding the plan that fits your needs for your home.


Read More


With health insurance, you protect your family from risk.


By having the right insurance plan, your family financial wellbeing is protected. Let us help you in finding the best plan for you.


Read More


We offer insurance packages for different types of businesses.


Whether it is insurance for your building, property, equipment, inventory or vehicles, we offer protection products & services.


Read More


Peoples First Insurance (Cecilia McMahon) has provided outstanding commercial insurance services for Beach Yana Inc., a Florida Non-Profit Organization located in Panama City Beach, Florida. Our Organization has a Club and a House to insure and have been with Peoples First Insurance since 2008! On behalf of Beach Yana Inc., I wish to thank Cecelia McMahon for her service to our Organization. Your dedication and commercial coverage experience is very much appreciated. Thank you!

~ C. Gamin, Panama City Beach




Recent News


March 25, 2015

Bundle Your Toys With Your Auto Policy


We insure more than just cars, learn about how you can bundle your toys with your auto policy!




February 18, 2015

2015 Bay County Health Expo


Come out and see us at the 2015 Bay County Health Expo at the Boardwalk Beach Resort Convention Center from 9am - 2pm. We will be there to provide you with helpful information about the benefits and affordability of Health Care.






Get A Free Quote

Let us provide you with a quote through our easy quote center.


Homeowners Insurance Quote
Auto Insurance Quote
Boat Insurance Quote
Commercial Insurance Quote
Benefits Insurance Quote




1002 West 23rd Street, #130
Panama City, FL 32405

850.770.7047 PHONE

850.785.6061 FAX



About Us

Why Peoples First?

Our Staff

Our Partners

Privacy Policy




Personal Insurance

Commercial Insurance


Quote Center







Client Stories